There’s a talent shortage – right?
Posted by jtarabini on April 22nd, 2010There have been many stories about the alleged lack of talent looming from the aging of America. But is it real? Peter Cappelli, management professor at the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School, likens alarms about a talent famine to breathless warnings from information technology professionals that computer systems could fail catastrophically when clocks rolled over to January 1, 2000.
In retrospect, of course, the Y2K hype was overblown. With that example in mind, the current sky-is-falling labor predictions could easily be called Gray2K.
It is true that in 2014, some 78 million baby boomers will fall between the ages of 50 and 68. But partly because many of them will work beyond the age of 55, the U.S. labor force will continue to grow during the next eight years, according to government projections. Other factors helping to soften the blow of baby boomer retirements include immigration and the prospect that U.S. companies will send more work offshore.
The real question surrounding the labor force in the next five to 10 years is where tightness in specific talent markets might emerge. Already some industries, occupations and geographies are showing signs of a squeeze.
The Conference Board of Canada recently reported that Canada is facing a workforce shortage once baby boomers recover financially from the recession. The organization reported that the current economic downturn has only delayed the anticipated labor shortage, and urged companies to plan for it.
Among the loudest voices sounding a Gray2K labor shortage alarm is consultant and author Roger Herman, who preached the importance of keeping good employees during the economic downturn in 1990. In 2003, he co-authored a book titled Impending Crisis: Too Many Jobs, Too Few People.
The book’s cover jacket displays a chart purporting to show a shortage of 10 million workers by 2010. That figure comes from the difference between what the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics projected as the civilian labor force in 2010 and the number of jobs it estimated for that year.
The BLS’ most recent projections show a smaller difference of 2.4 million between the two figures for 2014. In any event, the bureau explicitly warns that these figures are not strictly comparable. Norm Saunders, coordinator for research projects in the BLS’ projections program, says one problem in mixing the two data sets is that people can hold more than one job. But he’s not surprised the figures have been misrepresented.
“If it’s a good sound bite, some people will run with it,” he says.
Saunders says shortages in the U.S. labor market tend to be short-term and isolated, thanks to the laws of supply and demand: Wages rise in the area lacking enough workers, drawing new people into the field. He also says the overall labor force can increase beyond the BLS’ projections. A jump in wages could reverse a decline in the share of men in the workforce as well as accelerate the rate at which women are joining. Saunders also says immigration, which is assumed in U.S. Census Bureau population projections to be 900,000 documented immigrants arriving in the states each year, could be higher.
A larger percentage of older people have been working than in the past, with the trend likely to continue. Plus, Saunders adds, work at U.S. organizations in many cases can be sent to other countries. That’s been happening in growing numbers of service fields, including banking, software and travel services.
As a result, Saunders has a dim view of any looming wide-scale lack of talent.
“My sense is, it doesn’t exist,” he says. “There are lots of different ways for the supply to grow to meet the demand.”
Herman concedes that the bureau’s projections for the labor force and jobs are “apples and oranges.” Yet, he says, the numbers nonetheless point to trouble ahead in hiring.
“We don’t know if the shortage is 10 million or 14 million or 8 million,” Herman says. “The key is, we’re going to have a multimillion-person shortage of skilled workers.”
To ensure that you’re winning the war for talent by leveraging the high-end of the flexible workforce, visit www.msquared.com or call us at 888-818-2505.
Sources: www.workforce.com, www.UPI.com

Posted in 


