The Best Corporate Citizens
Posted by jtarabini on March 10th, 2010Corporate Responsibility Magazine (the new name of CRO Magazine) has announced its 11th annual 100 Best Corporate Citizens List. Hewlett-Packard, once tainted by a 2006 boardroom espionage case that brought down its chairman, topped the list. The Palo Alto, Calif., tech giant beat out the other companies considered–those that make up the Russell 1000 large-cap index–because of its high rankings in categories like corporate governance, philanthropy and environmental impact.
Hewlett-Packard had ranked fifth in 2009 and bumped Bristol-Myers Squibb from the top spot. Gabi Zedlmayer, the vice president of HP’s office of global social innovation, credits the company’s philanthropic efforts for the ranking, particularly its $23 million in “innovation grants” to universities. Good marketing has helped too. “We’ve done a better job of communicating the progress we’re making,” Zedlmayer says.
The 100 Best Corporate Citizens list, now in its 11th year, ranks companies based on publicly available information in seven categories: environmental impact, climate change, human rights, philanthropy, employee relations, financial performance and governance. The list’s creators assign a 19.5% weighting to environmental impact and employee relations, because they think they are what consumers, shareholders and employees care most about. Technology and electric utility businesses dominate the 2010 list, which has 25 of them. “Electric utilities are already highly regulated and transparent, and tech companies are young and mostly venture capital-backed and accustomed to transparency and dealing with investors,” says Jay Whitehead, the publisher of CRO.
Among this year’s high-profile no-shows: Google, which Whitehead describes as “one of the least transparent companies ever.” “Google’s opacity is high for a tech company,” he says. “They made a conscious decision early on not to disclose a lot, because they thought it would make them less competitive. ’Don’t be evil’ is their motto, but ‘Don’t be transparent’ is part of their culture.” Google rival Microsoft ranked No. 14.
The list suggests that companies have ramped up their do-gooding ways, or are at least doing a better job of promoting them. Between 2009 and 2010 the top company’s score improved by 66%, and the average score of all companies improved by 19%. A low score denotes good corporate citizenship, and the aggregate score of the top 100 companies was 30% less than the aggregate score last year.
Forty companies that made the 2009 list disappeared from it this year, including Goldman Sachs, which had the same score as last year. Only three companies, Intel, Starbucks and Cisco, have made the list all 11 years.
The 100 Best Corporate Citizens are selected from among the large-cap Russell 1000 companies, based on data provided by leading ESG investor data firm IW Financial. More information is at www.thecro.com.
For information on how to enhance your corporate citizenship strategies, contact M Squared Consulting at msquared@msquared.com or 1-888-818-2505.

Posted in 


